Mar 11, 2024

USCIRF Leaves Saudi Arabia After Government Official Insisted Chair to Remove Kippah

Washington, DC – The United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) ended early an official visit to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia after authorities required the USCIRF delegation to leave the Diriyah UNESCO World Heritage Site in Riyadh when the USCIRF Chair, Rabbi Abraham Cooper, refused their requests that he remove his religious head covering (kippah).

The Saudi government had invited the delegation, led by Chair Cooper and Vice Chair Reverend Frederick A. Davie, to tour the site on March 5, as part of their official visit to the country that had started on March 3. After several delays to the tour, officials requested that Cooper, an Orthodox Jewish Rabbi, remove his kippah while at the site and anytime he was to be in public, even though the Saudi Ministry of Foreign Affairs had approved the site visit. U.S. Embassy staff accompanying the USCIRF delegation supported and conveyed to Saudi officials Chair Cooper’s polite but resolute refusal to remove the kippah. Despite their efforts, site officials escorted the delegation off the premises after Chair Cooper indicated he sought no confrontation or provocation but as an observant Jew could not comply with a request to remove his kippah.

No one should be denied access to a heritage site, especially one intended to highlight unity and progress, simply for existing as a Jew,” said USCIRF Chair Cooper. “Saudi Arabia is in the midst of encouraging change under its 2030 Vision. However, especially in a time of raging antisemitism, being asked to remove my kippah made it impossible for us from USCIRF to continue our visit. We note, with particular regret, that this happened to a representative of a U.S. government agency promoting religious freedom. USCIRF looks forward to continuing conversations with the Saudi government about how to address the systematic issues that led to this troubling incident.”

Saudi officials’ request for Chair Cooper to remove his kippah was stunning and painful. It directly contradicted not only the government’s official narrative of change but also genuine signs of greater religious freedom in the Kingdom that we observed firsthand,” said USCIRF Vice Chair Davie. “We stand by our Chair and look forward to further discussions with our Saudi counterparts about protecting freedom of religion or belief for all. While we appreciate the various meetings we had in country with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Interior, the Human Rights Commission, and other interlocutors, this unfortunate incident starkly illustrates that much more work remains to be done for Saudi Arabia to align with international legal protections guaranteeing this fundamental right.”

The key to real progress for all who seek peace is to remember that respect is a two-way street,” Chair Cooper and Vice Chair Davie added.

USCIRF has recommended the U.S. Department of State designate Saudi Arabia as a “country of particular concern,” or CPC, for systematic, ongoing, and egregious religious freedom violations every year since 2000, most recently in its 2023 Annual Report. The State Department has designated Saudi Arabia a CPC repeatedly since 2004, most recently in December 2023; however, it has issued waivers on taking any action as outlined in the International Religious Freedom Act (IRFA). As USCIRF has emphasized repeatedly, including in this recent publication, the right to religious freedom, as protected under international human rights law, includes the freedom to wear religious symbols and attire.

 

###

The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) is an independent, bipartisan federal government entity established by the U.S. Congress to monitor, analyze, and report on religious freedom abroad. USCIRF makes foreign policy recommendations to the President, the Secretary of State, and Congress intended to deter religious persecution and promote freedom of religion and belief. To interview a Commissioner, please contact USCIRF at [email protected].

Additional Name(s): Шарлот Эдуард Валерьевич

Gender: Male

Perpetrator: Russia

Religion or Belief: Christian – Orthodox

Date of Detainment: November/22/2023

Current Status: Not Released

Most Recent Type of Abuse: Detainment

Reason for Persecution: Blasphemy (General) Blasphemy (Religious Figures) Online Activity

Nature of Charges: Blasphemy Insulting Public Officials & Institutions Spreading Propaganda & False or Misleading Ideas, Information, or Materials

Eduard Sharlot

Extra Bio Info:

Eduard Sharlot is detained for blasphemy.

On November 22, 2023, authorities detained Sharlot, a musician, at Pulkovo Airport and placed him under administrative arrest. Sharlot's arrest came after he posted videos on social media of himself burning his Russian passport, condemning Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and nailing his military ID and a photograph of Patriarch Kirill of the Russian Orthodox Church to a crucifix.

On December 2, 2023, Sharlot was transferred to Samara and sent to a pre-trial detention center on charges of "rehabilitation of Nazism" (Art. 354.1-4 RCC) and "insulting the religious feelings of believers" (Art. 148 RCC). Sharlot was later charged with damaging an official document out of personal interest (Art. 325-1 RCC).

Additional Name(s): Lina Mukherjee

Gender: Female

Perpetrator: Indonesia

Religion or Belief: Muslim – Unspecified/Other

Sentence: 2 Years' Imprisonment

Date of Sentencing: September//2023

Current Status: Not Released

Most Recent Type of Abuse: Imprisonment

Reason for Persecution: Blasphemy (Other) Dietary Practices Expression about Religion Online Activity

Nature of Charges: Hate Speech

Lina Lutfiawati

Extra Bio Info:

Lina Lutfiawati is imprisoned for her online religious expression.

In May 2023, police charged Lutfiawati with "disseminating information aimed at inflicting hatred or dissension on individuals and/or certain groups of community based on ethnic groups, religions, races, and inter-groups” (Art. 28 Electronic Information and Transaction (ITE)) for posting a video on social media in which she uttered an Islamic prayer before eating pork, a food considered haram in Islam. According to court documents, the Indonesia Ulema Council, a quasi-governmental organization, told the court Luftiawati's actions were blasphemous against Islam.

In September 2023, an Indonesian court sentenced Lutfiawati to two years in prison and fined her 250 million rupiah.