U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom Hearing
Religious Freedom, Violence, and U.S. Policy in Nigeria
Wednesday, September 28, 2022
10:30 AM – 12:00 PM
Virtual Hearing
The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) held a virtual hearing on religious freedom, violence, and U.S. policy in Nigeria.
In June 2022, a USCIRF delegation visited Nigeria to assess religious freedom conditions on the ground. Through this visit and other research, USCIRF confirmed poor religious freedom conditions for many Nigerians. Spreading violence by a plethora of nonstate actors threatens religious freedom in a myriad of ways, including through militant Islamist violence, identity-based violence at the intersection of religion, ethnicity, and geographic heritage, and violence impacting worship for both Muslims and Christians. Poor governance and weak state capacity drive much of this violence. Religious minorities and individuals with dissenting beliefs face particular challenges in exercising their rights to manifest and express their beliefs freely, including the threat of mob violence and detention and prosecution by state authorities.
Religious freedom violations in Nigeria take place within a broader context of human rights abuses and growing atrocity risk. This hearing explored the drivers of violence impacting religious freedom in Nigeria, how religion serves as both a mobilizer of violence and a capacity for peace in Nigerian society, and how the U.S. government can adjust its policy to address atrocity risk and violence impacting religious freedom in Nigeria.
Opening Remarks
Panel
Sep 16, 2022
In 2018, Kazakhstan arrested a group of men for participating in a WhatsApp group chat about Islam and sentenced them to multiple years in prison on fictitious terrorism and incitement-related charges. Last fall, the UN Working Group issued an opinion that their detention was arbitrary and that they should be released. Although the government of Kazakhstan has released a few individuals related to this case, five men still remain imprisoned.
Kazakhstan has regularly engaged with the U.S. government about possible religious freedom reforms, but it continues to severely limit this right through its 2011 religion law. USCIRF recommended in its 2022 Annual Report that the State Department place Kazakhstan on its Special Watch List for severe violations of religious freedom.
Freedom Now’s Legal Officer, Adam Lhedmat, and Advocacy Director, Matthew Schaaf join us today to discuss the case of the 5 Sunni Muslims who remain imprisoned for discussing their religious beliefs over WhatsApp.
Additional Name(s): Zhina (Mahsa) Amini, مهسا (ژینا) امینی
Gender: Female
Perpetrator: Iran
Religion or Belief: Unspecified
Reports of Torture: Yes
Reports of Medical Neglect: No
Date of Detainment: September//2022
Date of Death: September//2020
Current Status: Deceased
Religious Leader: No
Most Recent Type of Abuse: Detainment
Reason for Persecution: Religious Appearance Resisting State-Imposed Religious Systems Women’s Rights
Nature of Charges: Unknown
Mahsa Amini was detained and died in state custody in relation to state-imposed religious dress.
In September 2022, police tasked with enforcing public morals in Tehran arrested Amini for not wearing a "proper" hijab. Police reportedly beat her and took her to Vozara Police Station. Once she arrived to the police station, she was reportedly beaten again and later transferred to a hospital after suffering a heart attack or stroke. She reportedly fell into a coma.
On September 16, 2022, Amini passed away in the hospital.
USCIRF Press Release: USCIRF Calls for UN Commission of Inquiry on Iran After Crackdowns on Protests Against Mandatory Hijab October 14, 2022
USCIRF Press Release: USCIRF Condemns Iran’s Government For Killing of Young Woman with “Improper Hijab” September 21, 2022
"Masha Amini Died in Hospital at Moral Police Custody" Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA)
"مهسا امینی بر اثر جراحات ناشی از ضرب و شتم ماموران گشت ارشاد درگذشت" Iran International
USCIRF Commissioners Sharon Kleinbaum and Eric Ueland, Tweet, September 16, 2022
"Woman in Coma in Custody by Hejab Enforcement Causes Uproar in Iran" Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA)
"حال نامساعد جسمی یک زن جوان پس از انتقال به بازداشتگاه پلیس امنیت اخلاقی تهران/ فرماندهی انتظامی: “خودش دچار عارضه قلبی شد.”" Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA)